« Autistic Social Software |
Main
| spirtual perspective on community »
June 25, 2004Friendster is desperate; viral marketing failedFriendster realizes that it has lost the attention of its earliest adopters. This morning, Friendster sent a message to a select number of people that they labeled as "SuperFriends." It's a usability survey where they are asking for users' advice on an email campaign. There are four different potential emails that they sent out as screen shots. Here's a sample one: Subject: Friendster Now The tone of these messages is desperate, begging for attention of the original early adopters - the ones that Abrams told me were ruining his system. One focuses on Burning Man types; one mocks the old Power Point COO; one charges non-users with harming children; one is a desperate love poem. They're hyper American-centric, SF-centric, white collar, wannabee hipster, intentionally attempting sarcasm (and clarifying that below) and complete with 80s references. I guess Friendster isn't happy with the majority of its users being young and from Asia. Does this mean that Friendster has its tail between its legs about its early egotistical behavior? Apparently, viral marketing isn't working well enough anymore. Anyhow, you *have* to read the full message that these SuperFriends got (included in the full message). It has had me ROFL for hours. Below is the message that Friendster SuperFriend's received. The text was followed by four email screen shots; i have transcribed those for ease of access. Hi, As a SuperFriend, we would appreciate your feedback on a new email Please refer to the two versions for each group and reply to this email - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
*Which of the two versions do you prefer? (version 1 or 2) _____ *Is the email appropriate to send to active Friendster members? (yes/no) *Would you be likely to click the link and go to Friendster if you *After receiving this email, would you assume the Friendster website had *Would you be open to receiving similar emails from Friendster in the *Any additional comments?
*Which of the two versions do you prefer? (version 3 or 4) _____ *Is the email appropriate to send to inactive Friendster members? *Would you be likely to click the link and go to Friendster if you *After receiving this email, would you assume the Friendster website had *Would you be open to receiving similar emails from Friendster in the *Any additional comments?
Subject: Friendster Now So you're working. Who cares? You have a lifetime to work. What you'll really regret coughing and wheezing on your deathbed is not looking up all the old high-school friends, college buddies, summer camp alums, Burning Man acquaintances and ex'es who are just hoping you reach out and find them. And discovering new hiking partners, book groups and jam band fans. And setting up that person you really would date yourself if you were single. There's oh so much to do. Seriously, you should go to Burning Man. It's pretty cool. The jam band stuff we understand if you're not into. We just needed an example there. Thanks. www.friendster.com Oh, to make sure you keep getting these emails, please add Friendster to your email address book now. If for no other reason than it will look cool to have Friendster in your address book. Subject: Don't Tell Anyone You're our favorite subscriber. Seriously. I know we here at Friendster shouldn't play favorites, and our chief operating officer (he's the old guy in the office) told us not to do this, but seriously, you just totally rock. The way you reconnect with old friends. The way you've figured out just how small and interconnected the world really is. The way you discovered people with the same interests as you. We suspect you've even gotten a date out of Friendster, or that if you didn't, you could have if you needed to. Easy. With one of those three suspiciously hot people who keep popping up right above your friends list. For other people, we just use those pictures as cruel, aspirational temptation. But for you, they're totally getable. Hey, don't tell anyone we told you all of this. That old guy in the office will just start lecturing us again and pulling out charts and graphs and PowerPoint displays. He's such a loser. Thanks. www.friendster.com Oh, to make sure you keep getting these vaguely sarcastic emails, please add Friendster to your email address book now. If for no other reason than it will look cool to have Friendster in your address book. Subject: The Suffering You've Caused We totally miss you. By "we" we don't so much mean we here at Friendster. No, we like you and all, but really, to be honest, we're not all that close. No the "we" here are your real friends, the one you reconnected with through Friendster but have been ignoring as of late. They're the ones who are suffering. They're the ones who are crying late at night, screaming your name as they wait for you to contact them. Not to mention all the old high-school friends, college buddies and ex-es who are just hoping you reach out and find them. And the hiking partners, book groups and Wilco-heads who need you to discover them. It's them, the children, who are suffering. That's right, the children. So come on back. We've made it easier for you, getting much faster and easier to navigate as we've grown. We won't judge. We're just here to help you. Help you help the children. Thanks. www.friendster.com Oh, to make sure you keep getting these vaguely sarcastic emails, please add Friendster to your email address book now. If for no other reason than it will look cool to have Friendster in your address book. Subject: We Still Care We miss you. There, we said it. It feels better. So we're going to do everything we can to bring you back to Friendster, all the way up to that John Cusack boom box Say Anything bit. So before it all comes to that, just come back to Friendster. We've already made it easier for you, getting much faster and clearer as we've grown. Now, in just minutes you can find people you've been wondering about: friends from summer camp, college roommates, high school buddies, cousins, people you used to date, people you wanted to date, these people you know, and don't know, are connected to each other and what a beautifully small world it really is. Or date, or help a friend find a date. We don't care. We just want you back in our lives. And we can tell you that you want the same thing. We can see it... in your eyes. The light, the heat. Your eyes, we feel complete. See, we told you. Thanks. www.friendster.com Oh, to make sure you keep getting these vaguely sarcastic emails, please add Friendster to your email address book now. If for no other reason than it will look cool to have Friendster in your address book. Category: friendster Posted by zephoria at June 25, 2004 4:16 PM
| TrackBack
|
Comments (16)
Superfriends?
Frankly, I'd rather they call it Super Best Friends, but that's just me.
And then, once you start having Superfriends, isn't that having like multiple best friends? Or a favorite child? Won't all my friends want to be my superfriens? Lame.
Posted by Graham | June 25, 2004 5:00 PM
Posted on June 25, 2004 17:00
Wow, as a copywriter, I have to say that these letters are facinating attempts at targeting a demographic. But, as any smarty can tell you, the minute your attempts to "target" the reader are transparent (as they so clearly are in these emails) it starts looking desperate.
For what it's worth, I visited Friendster today for the first time in over a month. Tribe, meanwhile, I visit almost daily.
Posted by Arile | June 25, 2004 9:11 PM
Posted on June 25, 2004 21:11
For what it's worth as well, I count 4 'marketing' emails from Flickr this morning in my Inbox. 7 from LinkedIn, 3 from Tribe, and 2 from Orkut, all from this year.
I count zero "marketing" emails from Friendster, I assume because they have been too busy with getting their site fast, which has apparently worked, from the looks of it. I've had better success getting into Friendster the past 2 weeks than I have Orkut and Tribe, due to "downtime" messages.
After reading these and looking at all of the marketing spam I get from other places, I wonder how many other social networking sites actually ask their users what sort of email they'd rather get. Does Orkut or Tribe have a "SuperFriends" group ? Maybe they're doing this now because Abrams is out of the picture now ?
Posted by Mike | June 26, 2004 10:03 AM
Posted on June 26, 2004 10:03
As a so-called "SuperFriend" I got this as well. My feelings on Friendster right now. They are going to crater within 12 months I figure, and it WON'T be pretty.
Posted by Ryan Schultz | June 26, 2004 7:43 PM
Posted on June 26, 2004 19:43
Yes, this may be desperate marketing. It may also be the exact type of marketing that works. Why? I wouldn't be surprised if they concocted up this whole idea of sending around feedback questions on ridiculous emails SOLELY to get these connected people to bring up friendster on their blogs and in conversation. And because of this discussion, what do people do? They remember friendster, they log into their old accounts, and they take a quick run through friendster once again.
Friendster has been off my radar for a few months. But after hearing about these ridiculous emails, I most certainly signed back on and will probably sign on again tomorrow or the next day. And this is for no other reason than it is now back on my radar.
No press is bad press holds true in this case.
Posted by Dan | June 26, 2004 9:49 PM
Posted on June 26, 2004 21:49
just saw this from socialsoftware.weblogsinc.com:
Friendster traffic on Alexa
if the sample size is all people who have the alexa toolbar installed, then I doubt there will be a "crater".
Posted by Mike | June 26, 2004 11:56 PM
Posted on June 26, 2004 23:56
Tribe.net is dying. Friendster is getting desperate. Orkut is ascending. And Tickle is blowing everyone away.
Alexa agrees
Posted by Mike | June 27, 2004 7:41 AM
Posted on June 27, 2004 07:41
I don't see Orkut ascending there. They have been higher in the past. Tickle is not a surprise, they have been consistently higher than all for quite some time, and Monster.com's buy of them will most likely continue that trend.
I don't see Friendster getting desperate at all, they have been consistent on that graph.
Note: that graph is logarithmic, so Orkut will have a tougher time to catch Friendster than Friendster will to catch up to Tickle.
Posted by Mike | June 27, 2004 8:55 AM
Posted on June 27, 2004 08:55
Holly has the most hysterical advice to Friendster on this one:
- The loser who sycophanticly tries to fit in with the cool group, don't be that guy.
- The aging has-been trying to prove he's still with-it by using contrived pop culture references, don't be that guy.
- The outcast begging for friends and acceptance, don't be that guy.
- The marketer who latches onto the canned irreverence trend by sending hammy, schmaltzy, faux-personal mass-emailings in effort to prove their product's coolness to their target demographic, don't be that guy.
- That same marketer who approaches a segment of that same target audience to solicit opinions on which feigningly "off-the-cuff" plea will garner the best results, seriously, DON'T be that guy.
Posted by zephoria | June 27, 2004 11:31 PM
Posted on June 27, 2004 23:31
This is really embarrassing. It sounds like a script that a telemarketer would read to you over the phone. Ugh. Who writes this stuff anyway?
Posted by EsmeV | June 29, 2004 9:44 AM
Posted on June 29, 2004 09:44
Mike wrote: "Tribe.net is dying." It is? Among the social niche that uses it (mostly Burners and members of other fringe subcultures), it seems to be doing pretty well.
Posted by Ariel | June 30, 2004 11:04 AM
Posted on June 30, 2004 11:04
dear friendster,
i'd rather be on myspace.
sincerely,
everyone
Posted by Michael | July 6, 2004 9:56 AM
Posted on July 6, 2004 09:56
dear friendster,
i'd rather be on myspace.
sincerely,
everyone
Posted by Michael | July 6, 2004 9:57 AM
Posted on July 6, 2004 09:57
I hate those marketing people who misuse the term "usability" to cover their marketing rubbish. :-(
Posted by Lucomo | July 8, 2004 9:18 AM
Posted on July 8, 2004 09:18
I hate those marketing people who misuse the term "usability" to cover their marketing rubbish. :-(
Posted by Lucomo | July 8, 2004 9:19 AM
Posted on July 8, 2004 09:19
I hate those marketing people who misuse the term "usability" to cover their marketing rubbish. :-(
Posted by Lucomo | July 8, 2004 9:20 AM
Posted on July 8, 2004 09:20